
Welcome to the first ever DSDraws Review! This is a series of posts in which I give my honest opinion on things such as art supplies, movies, games, tv shows, and just about anything else. I’ll break each one down by listing some pros and cons, then finish it off with my final overall verdict and recommendation.
For this inaugural post, I have decided to review Blackwing pencils. I picked up some a few years ago and have used them in many sketches and drawings. The Blackwing line of pencils include many varieties, but this review will focus specifically on the Blackwing Matte style that I have been using.

The Blackwing pencils actually have a long legacy that I was unaware of for the longest time. It began in the 1930’s when the Eberhard Faber Pencil Company introduced the original 602 model. They were quite popular during that time. However in 1998, the machines used to produce the pencils broke down and the manufacturer decided to end production of them instead of replacing them due to high costs and slowing sales. The pencil remained extinct and over the years developed a cult following that lead to some pencils selling for as much as $40! (that’s a lot for just a pencil) It wasn’t until the year 2010 that the company Palomino revived the Blackwing brand and expanded it to what it is today with multiple models.
I’ve been an artist for many years and I was painfully oblivious to this pencil and it’s legacy until fairly recently. I first discovered them from watching a fellow artist’s drawing video online. He was using it during some sketches and I thought to myself “hmm what is that pencil with the strange eraser end?’ I discovered it was a Blackwing pencil after some research online and became more curious, so I dove a bit deeper. It was then that I learned that some of the best artists at the time used the original 602 Blackwing, including animator Chuck Jones and Walt Disney and his nine old men! These guys swore by this pencil and it was then that I knew I had to give them a try myself. I needed to use the chosen tool of some of the best animators ever! Alright let’s get to the review.
The Pros
Let’s start with the pros. At first glance you might think this is just like any pencil out there but what makes them physically stand out is the unique ferule and eraser. The Blackwing ferule is longer and rectangular shaped with a removable and replaceable eraser. This is the feature that truly makes the Blackwing pencil unique as no other traditional wooden pencil has this to my knowledge. It’s honestly a pretty neat feature that drew my attention to it more. I try not to erase a ton when drawing, but having the ability to swap in a new eraser when needed seemed cool to me.
The first thing I noticed when picking one of the pencils up for the first time is how nice it was. It wasn’t heavy, but the wood felt dense and solid with a smooth black coating that gave it a super high quality look. After sharpening it many times with different types of sharpeners, not once has the the wood split, the graphite crack, or the coating peel away. I can see why these were the go to pencil for the best artists of the 1930’s. The pencils exude a sense of high quality that almost forces your drawing skill to level up just by using it. These pencils are also noticeably longer than other pencils, so that’s another thing that extends their life. I specifically picked up the Matte version because I heard it was softer graphite better suited for artists. It is indeed very soft (comparable to about a 4B pencil) and writes incredibly smooth. It felt like drawing with a stick of butter which I loved.
The Cons
Now let’s get to the cons. I mentioned before that the unique ferule and removable eraser is the Blackwing’s major calling card, but it has it’s faults. Because the ferule is so uniquely shaped, you cannot use a traditional pencil extender when it starts to get smaller. I’m one who likes to get the most life out of my supplies, so I’ve used pencil extenders for past pencils to get a bit more out of them before throwing them out. Blackwing does sell a dedicated extender for their pencils, but you have to commit to theirs only. I haven’t used their extender, but the shape of their ferule makes me concerned with how comfortable that would be in your palm while using the extender to get more life out of the pencil. The removeable eraser is cool, but in my experience I’ve found that it can be a bit stubborn or even impossible to remove. The first couple of pencils I tried had erasers that were completely stuck in the ferule. I nearly cut up my fingers trying to grip the edges of the metal holder trying to pry it out. Now that could have just been a few faulty pencils, but the fact I came across it multiple times when that is one of their big calling cards is definitely cause for concern and something to keep in mind.
The other thing is the price. These bad boys are not cheap. A set of twelve pencils right now costs $34, which makes the price for each pencil nearly $3! For me personally that is a lot for a set of pencils. I understand the quality bumps up the price, but oof that price hurts my wallet every time I see it.
Final Verdict
After spending the last few years using these Blackwing Matte pencils pretty consistently, I can say with confidence that I would recommend them to any artist. They are high quality and write very smooth. Their longer length extends the life of each pencil and the unique ferule and eraser is a nice touch. Overall, I believe the pros outweigh the cons here and suggest every artist give the Blackwing pencils a try at least once. Not everyone likes using traditional wooden pencils these days, but if you do and don’t mind spending more for the high quality, then these pencils are definitely worth your time.
DSDraws Approved!

Subscriber Exclusive Art
Get an exclusive early look at a rough sketch for a recent commission.









